Jack (Scott Bailey) has what every man would want; a beautiful and successful wife, two smart and pretty daughters, a big house on Philadelphia's Main Line and a great job in a publishing house. He also has a secret that has been eating him alive for most of his life. Like many men and women, Jack choose the path of "normalcy" to the American Dream rather than face the fact that he's attracted to men. He tries as hard as he can to be the faithful husband and good father until one night, he can't do it anymore. Pete (Darryl Stephens) is just a guy in Philadelphia who happens to have a history of getting involved with married men. His father (Richard Lawson) and his soon-to-be stepmom (Leslie Zemeckis) are on him to find someone who's actually available and to settle down. A chance encounter at a party leads Jack straight to Peter who will change his life forever and upend everything Jack has built. What was supposed to be a one-night stand turns into a once-in-a-lifetime love for both of them.