Review by Raymond Murray
By: Raymond Murray
In-House Review - Jan 03 2012
No one will confuse Polish-born director Grodecki with a great filmmaker, but one has to give him credit for being able to take his sexual obsession (in this case, the young male prostitutes of Prague) and successfully build a cottage industry (Not A...
Read More
No one will confuse Polish-born director Grodecki with a great filmmaker, but one has to give him credit for being able to take his sexual obsession (in this case, the young male prostitutes of Prague) and successfully build a cottage industry (Not Angels But Angels, Body without Soul) on the subject. This deliriously hyperventilating drama recounts a teen boy's tragic descent into prostitution, violence and . -year-old Marek (Mirek Caslavka) leaves his dreary small-town life for the beautiful but treacherous streets of Prague. He quickly is lured by a greasy pimp into selling his body to the many tourists who flock to the city for its cathedrals, castles and tender male flesh. Emboldened by his early appeal, Marek and his handsome streetwise buddy David decide to go into the teen flesh trade themselves. But kinky johns, all-too-available and their own self-destructive natures propel them instead into a hellish world that offers no return. This seedy world is vividly created (filmed with many actual prostitutes in Prague's train stations and sex clubs) but is marred by Grodecki's heavy hand and his inability to end the film (there are at least four faux endings). Regarding the title: It refers to a plant, which according to East Indian folklore, grows under the gallows from the sperm of hanged men.
Review by Amos Lassen
By: Amos Lassen
The Road to Degradation
"MANDRAGORA"
Amos Lassen
"Mandragora" is one of two films I received from WaterBearer Films for review this week and it held me spellbound. It is a brutal and realistic look at male prostitution in Prague, Czec...
Read More
The Road to Degradation
"MANDRAGORA"
Amos Lassen
"Mandragora" is one of two films I received from WaterBearer Films for review this week and it held me spellbound. It is a brutal and realistic look at male prostitution in Prague, Czechoslovakia. Prague has recently been discovered by gay movie makers as an ideal site to make movies. I suppose this is due to the plethora of beautiful men and incredible beautiful scenery. The porn companies have been filming there for several years now and Prague has emerged as one of the gay capitals of Europe. This astonishing film is tells the tale of the seductive world of male prostitution which promises money but ultimately with the loss of self respect and loneliness.
Marek (Miroslav Caslavka) is incredibly beautiful and a stunning screen presence. At 15, he left his home village and finds himself surrounded by petty thieves who wear beautiful clothes. Hs father wanted him to go to school and have a good life and the collision between father and son is the catalyst which causes Marek to move to Prague. Once there, a pimp named Honza convinces him to become a rabbit or male whore. Marek's first experience with a wealthy American disappoints but he nevertheless returns to the streets where he meets another "rabbit", David, and the two form an alliance to escape Honza's grip. Together they manage to see and to experience everything the night life of Prague has to offer.
Their lives become revolving doors where people cone and go but not before leaving scars. There is always the threat f addiction and HIV infection and eventually they sink to the world of gay porn. A brutal scene in which Marek is sodomized by David results in a police raid and Honza miraculously comes to their aid. They return to him and to the world of and illicit sex, to a life filled with hallucinations and an unsavory clientele. Marek's father comes to Prague and discovers his son's activities and the final scene is sad to the point of devastation.
This is a downbeat film and I found it hard to believe that people live can this and can actually sink to such levels. The movie is a voyeuristic look into the world of hustling and professes to moralize on the scene of gay male prostitution. It is extremely difficult to see a young boy stripped of his innocence and subjected to the depravity of the milieu where he finds himself. Just when you think he is going to find some sense of stability he is sucked up again into a world that is depicted as having no sense of morality. It is Marek's own lack of self-esteem which causes his downfall.
Although the movie is ostensibly about the world of prostitution in Prague is even more so about Czechoslovakia itself. I remember taking a course in Czech history and learning how the Czech people struggled to achieve national unity only to be defeated by Nazi Germany and afterwards becoming part of Stalin's Soviet Union. This caused the privatization of national symbols and assets and because of that the movie industry declined considerably. It is wonderful to see a movie that has come out of Slovakia that is both meaningful and well made.
Watching this movie is a wrenching experience, especially watching Marek fall victim to such a terrible world. His violation and isolation will break even the strongest of hearts. The story of Marek and his fall is the story of the fall of civilization which when will disintegrate and die. It is, as if to say, that the world is plummeting toward a dead end.
The actors are nothing short of wonderful. Their performances are painstakingly believable and they perform with passion. The film is dark and cruel as it descends into the belly of the underworld of Prague. But the direction is fine-more than fine, actually and the performances are just amazing. The movie sweeps us up into a world of compassion and humiliating degradation. Maybe the editing is not perfect and the sound needs work, this is a very important film that should not be missed.
Review by nick
By: nick
This is definitely a low budget film that would never be categorized as award winning but if you have a respect towards the cinematographic arts I highly recommend you watch this masterpiece. The story keeps you on the edge of your seat. I admit that...
Read More
This is definitely a low budget film that would never be categorized as award winning but if you have a respect towards the cinematographic arts I highly recommend you watch this masterpiece. The story keeps you on the edge of your seat. I admit that going into it I only wanted to see Marek and David get it on (there's a sort of connection between the two.. Dave is ultimately straight but you kind of get the feeling that Marek has the hots for Dave)..... Not to spoil the movie but this film touches upon the hardships one feels while asserting themselves as part of society... almost giving into the temptations and glorified hells that present themselves as the easy street. This movie grips the heart and is without a doubt one of the best movies I have seen in a long, long time. PLEASE, PLEASE watch it... the story is beyond powerful even amid the cultural differences we in Western society may judge it by.. 5 stars all the way
Review by TheCount
By: TheCount
When I first heard of this film, I was uncertain whether I would like it, but I watched it on DVD, figuring at least, well, I could turn it off any time, if it was REALLY bad. What I saw riveted and repulsed me at the same time, but nonetheless fille...
Read More
When I first heard of this film, I was uncertain whether I would like it, but I watched it on DVD, figuring at least, well, I could turn it off any time, if it was REALLY bad. What I saw riveted and repulsed me at the same time, but nonetheless filled me with emotion. If I come away from a film with powerful feelings, I give it high points for that. And I didn't turn it off.
Do the production and script have faults? Yes, a multitude. Since this Web page provides a reviewer's synopsis, I won't give another, and I'll just add everything the synopsis says is bad about the film is true and then some. HOWEVER, what came across to me most strongly was the director's compassion for his characters, especially the protagonist, Marek. Through all his ups and horrendous downs (and sometimes bad dialog, whether from script flaws or poor translation I cannot say), I still felt for Marek and his sad situation. These feelings only increased during the course of the fiilm. Was it too long? Yes. Did it have trouble ending? Yes. Did it hammer too hard on its message? Yes, yes, yes.
Yet, after the fade to black, I was haunted by intense images of something wonderful lost, a crushed life, and premature, tragic death. During the course of the film, I came to truly care about Marek and regretted his loss. Though the film does have such pretentions, it is definitely NOT for the "haute cinema" crowd. Only watch this movie if you can suspend the bulk of your film-critic tendencies. If, instead, your main interest is an experience of great emotional power and empathy, then this is the film for you.